Casper
Casper Original Pillow
$65Cheaper
Best Bed Pillows · head-to-head
Casper Original Pillow vs Brooklinen Down Pillow (Mid-Plush)
A sourced, side-by-side comparison. Casper Original Pillow is cheaper at $65. Every spec and price links to its source.
No photo yet
Brooklinen
Brooklinen Down Pillow (Mid-Plush)
$79
Which is better: the Casper Original Pillow or Brooklinen Down Pillow (Mid-Plush)?
On the specs we track, they're closely matched. The Casper Original Pillow is the cheaper at $65.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Prices verified at capture; live price may differ.
Full spec sheet
✓ marks the stronger figure where "more" — or "less", for price and weight — is unambiguously better.
| Spec | Casper Original Pillow | Brooklinen Down Pillow (Mid-Plush) |
|---|---|---|
| US price | $65 | $79 |
| Brand | Casper | Brooklinen |
| Released | — | — |
| Fill material | polyester microfiber down-alternative, pillow-within-a-pillow construction | Canadian white duck down + feather blend (Mid-Plush: 20% down clusters / 80% feathers) |
| Loft height (in) | 2 | 6 |
| Firmness level | medium-firm (soft outer layer, firmer inner support pillow) | mid-plush (also offered in Plush and Firm) |
| Cooling technology | — | — |
| Adjustable fill | No | No |
| Sleeper position | back and stomach (average-weight back sleepers report the best fit on the Mid loft) | side and back sleepers (stomach sleepers should choose the Plush option instead) |
| Cover material | 100% cotton, percale weave | 100% cotton sateen, 400 thread count, antimicrobial treatment |
| Certifications | — | OEKO-TEX |
| Machine washable | Yes | Yes |
Sources — Casper Original Pillow: mattressclarity.com (verified 2026-08-01). Brooklinen Down Pillow (Mid-Plush): mattressclarity.com (verified 2026-08-01).
What's the difference between the Casper Original Pillow and Brooklinen Down Pillow (Mid-Plush)?
Where the two actually differ on the specs we track (5 of 9). Matching specs are omitted.
- Fill material: Casper Original Pillow polyester microfiber down-alternative, pillow-within-a-pillow construction vs Brooklinen Down Pillow (Mid-Plush) Canadian white duck down + feather blend (Mid-Plush: 20% down clusters / 80% feathers)
- Loft height (in): Casper Original Pillow 2 vs Brooklinen Down Pillow (Mid-Plush) 6
- Firmness level: Casper Original Pillow medium-firm (soft outer layer, firmer inner support pillow) vs Brooklinen Down Pillow (Mid-Plush) mid-plush (also offered in Plush and Firm)
- Sleeper position: Casper Original Pillow back and stomach (average-weight back sleepers report the best fit on the Mid loft) vs Brooklinen Down Pillow (Mid-Plush) side and back sleepers (stomach sleepers should choose the Plush option instead)
- Cover material: Casper Original Pillow 100% cotton, percale weave vs Brooklinen Down Pillow (Mid-Plush) 100% cotton sateen, 400 thread count, antimicrobial treatment